NH HOOF Betting Report

Seasons 2021–22 to 2025–26 • Historical Analysis and Live Forward Test

Overview

This report covers four National Hunt seasons starting with 2021–22. We compare the raw market baseline (back every runner at level stakes) with the system under its original rules and with two refinements: excluding runners priced above BSP 20.0, and limiting selections to the top three by speed rating. We then combine both filters.


Market Structure Baseline — All Runners (Level £100 Stakes)

Backing every runner in every UK NH race (benchmark for market efficiency)
Season Total Runners Winners Hit % Stake £ BF Return £ BF Profit £ Yield BSP %
2021–2219,5402,43012.4%1,954,0001,846,562−107,438−5.5%
2022–2318,4642,19511.9%1,846,4001,830,348−16,052−0.9%
2023–2417,5202,11512.1%1,752,0001,618,140−133,860−7.6%
2024–2518,0072,25312.5%1,800,7001,763,419−37,281−2.1%
Total73,5318,99312.2%7,353,1007,058,469−294,631−4.0%
The baseline demonstrates a small, consistent negative expectation (≈ −4% overall), confirming that any positive system ROI represents genuine outperformance rather than market drift. Backing every runner loses between 1–7% per season (average ≈ −4%). The strike rate holds around 12%, so annual yield shifts reflect normal price variance rather than changes in field size or race mix.

Core & Forum Results — Method‑Specific Tables

Notes: 2021–22 & 2022–23 are rules‑applied back tests (standardised to BSP). 2023–24 & 2024–25 are forum‑posted selections published around 11:00 and taken at Betfair prices at time of posting (BF @ ~11:00) — not final BSP. The unified 4‑year table applies the rules uniformly to BSP across all seasons.


Rules Applied (Back‑Tested) — 2021–22 & 2022–23 (BSP)

Original rule‑set applied to data (BSP basis)
Season Bets Winners Hit % BF Profit £ Yield BSP %
2021–2288913014.6%£11,84213.3%
2022–2378610913.9%£16,49621.0%
Total1,67523914.3%£28,33816.9%

The initial analysis examined data spanning 2010 to 2022–23 and showed profitable outcomes in every season except one. There were some additional data and rule added for the 2021-22 season which meant that the earlier year were only mildly indicative, which is why we concentrated on the data from 2021-22 and 2022-23. These two years looked too good to be true, but even if they performed at a much lower level they would still make a profit.

Forum Selections (Posted ~11:00, BF price at posting) — 2023–24 & 2024–25


Live selections posted in the forum (taken at Betfair price at ~11:00; not settled to BSP)
Season Bets Winners Hit % BF Profit £ (@11:00) Yield BF@11 %
2023–24 Dec - Apr78513216.8%£9,52012.1%
2024–25 Nov - Apr84111613.8%-£2,830-3.4%
Total1,62624815.3%£6,6904.1%
Note: Prices are fixed at time of posting (~11:00) and may differ from BSP due to market drift.


Throughout the 2023–24 and 2024–25 seasons, I posted the day’s selections to the forum around 11 a.m., using the Betfair prices available at that time. These prices reflect what could reasonably have been achieved by anyone following the forum posts in real time. The 2024–25 season proved disappointing compared with prior years, producing a loss (29% of bank) after three profitable campaigns. However, taken together, the two forum seasons still returned just over 4% to BF@11 prices, showing that the rule set continued to hold an edge at posting time. The shortfall in 2024–25 likely reflects normal variance and fewer higher-priced winners rather than any structural shift in performance.

Unified Rules (BSP basis) — 2021–22 to 2024–25

Same rule‑set applied uniformly to BSP across all four seasons
Season Bets Winners Hit % BF Profit £ Yield BSP %
2021–2288913014.6%£11,84213.3%
2022–2378610913.9%£16,49621.0%
2023–2478611414.5%£9,84512.5%
2024–2583010112.2%−£5,722−6.9%
Total3,29145413.8%£32,4619.9%

Over the four-season period, applying the rules uniformly to BSP produced three profitable years and one losing year, with a cumulative gain of £32,461 (a 9.9% return on stake). Strike rate held steady between 13.9% and 14.6% for the first three seasons but fell to 12.2% in 2024–25 — a meaningful decline that contributed to the loss that year. The downturn coincided with a reduction in higher-priced winners, suggesting that variance and market composition, rather than a fundamental system failure, were the main factors. Even so, the overall four-year record indicates that the core rule set has been broadly robust.

That said it's worth investigating whether any additional rules related to price might improve or smooth returns



Filtered Variant — Excluding BSP > 20.0 Runners

System results after removing runners with BSP > 20.0
SeasonBetsWinnersHit % BF Profit £Yield BSP %
2021–2283712615.1+6,708+8.01
2022–2373010314.1+6,224+8.53
2023–2473011015.1+5,839+8.00
2024–2575010113.5+2,278+3.04
Total3,04744014.4+21,049+6.91
Since the fall in returns in the 2024-25 season came from a lack of big priced winners (there were only 4, with previous seasons giving 10, 8 and 5 big priced winners), then I analysed the results removing bands of runners based on price. The best return came from removing all runner above 15.0+ 16+ 17+ 18+ 19+ 20+ etc ... The best compromise price was 20.0

After excluding runners above BSP 20.0, all four seasons are profitable at BSP. Yearly yields cluster between +3% and +8.5%, with strike rate rising to ~14%, materially reducing variance.


Filtered Variant — Top 3 in Speed Ratings

Results restricting selections to top 3 speed‑rated runners
SeasonBetsWinnersHit % BF Profit £Yield BSP %
2021–2269810815.5+15,560+22.29
2022–236229114.6+14,829+23.84
2023–246519614.8+5,978+9.18
2024–256608813.3+2,683+4.06
Total2,63138314.6+39,050+14.84
Another area of interest was restricting bets based on speed firures.

Concentrating on the top three speed‑rated runners yields four straight winning years with a strong aggregate BSP yield (+14.8%) and reduced sample size (quality over quantity).


Combined Rules — Top 3 Speed Ratings & BSP ≤ 20.0

Results applying both filters together
SeasonBetsWinnersHit % BF Profit £Yield BSP %
2021–2265810415.8+9,226+14.02
2022–235778715.1+7,934+13.75
2023–246069415.5+5,672+9.36
2024–255968814.8+9,083+15.24
Total2,43737315.3+31,915+13.10
Combining both filters produces four consecutive winning years with consistent double‑digit BSP yields (avg. +13%). This defines a stable core strategy for forward testing.

2025–26 Live Forward Test

For 2025–26 the two approaches identified in the earlier analysis were run live through the Patternform forum. Selections were posted before the races were run. For the 5 Rule Approach, most selections were posted at or near 11 a.m. with the exchange price available at the time.

5 Rule Approach (Classic HOOF)

Live forum selections, November 2025 to April 2026
MonthBetsWinsStaked £Returned £ Strike RateProfit £ROI
Nov177221,7701,83812.4%+68+3.8%
Dec168301,6802,34017.9%+660+39.3%
Jan120251,2001,77920.8%+579+48.2%
Feb115211,1501,30618.3%+156+13.6%
Mar120221,2001,21418.3%+14+1.1%
Apr107141,0701,11213.1%+42+3.9%
Total8071348,0709,58916.6%+1,519+18.8%
The 5 Rule Approach completed the live season with 134 winners from 807 bets and a profit of £1,519 to £10 level stakes, an ROI of +18.8%.

7 Rule Approach (System 2 HOOF)

Live forum selections, November 2025 to April 2026
MonthBetsWinsStaked £Returned £ Strike RateProfit £ROI
Nov136201,3601,65114.7%+291+21.4%
Dec130231,3001,67017.7%+370+28.4%
Jan89198901,27521.3%+385+43.3%
Feb93199301,29420.4%+364+39.2%
Mar95179501,06617.9%+116+12.2%
Apr841084076411.9%-76-9.1%
Total6271086,2707,71917.2%+1,450+23.1%
The 7 Rule Approach completed the live season with 108 winners from 627 bets and a profit of £1,450 to £10 level stakes, an ROI of +23.1%. April was the only losing month.

The important point is that these were no longer back-tested results. Both approaches were followed live through a complete November-to-April National Hunt season, with selections published before the races were run.

Summary & 2026–27

  • Historical baseline: Backing every runner in every NH race lost around 4% overall in the 2021–22 to 2024–25 benchmark, providing a useful comparison for the HOOF results.

  • Original rule set: Applied uniformly to BSP from 2021–22 to 2024–25, the core rules produced three winning seasons from four and an overall return of +9.9%.

  • Price and speed refinements: The historical analysis found that the BSP ≤ 20.0 filter and the Top 3 Speed filter both improved consistency. Used together, they produced four profitable historical seasons in the test period.

  • 2025–26 live 5 Rule Approach: 807 bets, 134 winners, £1,519 profit to £10 level stakes and +18.8% ROI.

  • 2025–26 live 7 Rule Approach: 627 bets, 108 winners, £1,450 profit to £10 level stakes and +23.1% ROI.

  • Forward evidence: Both approaches therefore moved beyond historical testing and completed the 2025–26 season profitably using selections posted before racing.

2026–27: HOOF ratings and cards will no longer be included as part of the normal Patternform subscription. Patternform will instead host a private HOOF forum area for people who subscribe to HOOF with Tony Drapkin. The HOOF system selections and related discussion will be posted in that restricted area during the season.